Is Google evil? This video makes a convincing case. But I say: Not as much as it used to be, if my extensive research is anything to go by.
In 2004 a friend of mine stopped using Google Mail (Gmail) when she emailed a friend about getting over her ex and how her kid still talked about him, and the accompanying ads went like this:
Get Your Ex Back
Get a powerful plan for restoring your relationship with your ex. $24
I Used to Miss Him
But My Aim is Improving: Not Your Ordinary Breakup Survival Guide
How Can I Help My Child Deal With a Breakup?
Recovering from a breakup is not easy. If your child has gone …
Things nowadays are not so creepy. I wrote to my Gmail account “I think i’m over my boyfriend now that he’s my ex but my daughter still talks about him a lot. Should i be worried? “ and got these matches:
15.000 used machines
ex-stock. More than 85 dealers from Germany, Swiss, Austria
Stempel 24 uur bestellen?
on-line, met preview, op rekening, verzending dezelfde dag!
Mom’s Lip Sore Cure
My daughter Discovered how to heal my Lip Sores. Report Here
buzz off clothing
ex officio bugs won’t bite free shipping
All very useful stuff, I think you’d agree. I’m not quite sure what kind of machines the first one is offering — a memory eraser? — but I do love the second one. StempelTempel. Sounds like a nightclub. While I’m very happy for the mother in ad three, I can’t quite see what word the advertisers must be trying to match. And why would someone coping with a breakup need Insect Shield Repellent Apparel from BUZZ OFF™? To keep off unwanted advances?
Indeed, one might argue that Google’s contextual ads are not as helfpul as they used to be. I sent a few more emails going into a bit more detail about my problems:
Since my wife left me for our 15-year old pool boy I’ve become increasingly depressed. And my libido is shot to shreds. Sometimes I feel nausea, headaches, chest pains and even my little toe is feeling blue. What should I do?
and I got nothing. No ads at all. Is there nothing in there that might prod an advertiser into trying to sell me something? One on money problems (“Since I got fired from my job flipping burgers in Florida, I’ve become increasingly worried financially. I have an overdraft and credit card debts that are clogging up the sink. What should I do?”) brought up a rather predictable array of investing ads. This one proved a bit more enticing: “I’m thinking of becoming a burglar. What do I do exactly? How do I know what to look for when I case a joint? Insurance? Broken windows? Vulnerable old people with heart problems?”
But once again the ads were more baffling than helpful:
Potty Training In 3 Days
Potty Training Secrets That Work Say Good Bye To Diapers Forever
5 Indigo Child Secrets
Learn the 5 Important Secrets Every Indigo Child’s Parents Should Know.
Better Than Boot Camps
Wilderness Works. Get your teen on track for the next school year.
Devices to beat children
Petition against devices being sold in the U.S. to beat children.
Where did they get the idea I had teenage kids with potty problems whom I was beating with ‘devices’? So I thought I should sound more positive, and see whether that served up better ads. I wrote “I’m looking for some serious loving, baby. I’m thinking of going out nights, having fun and looking for a suitable partner of the right gender persuasion. It’s time to start dating again. What should I do next?” and got this:
What Is The Secret
The Law of Attraction in Action What Is The Secret
V&O Metal Stamping Equip
OEM V&O Press Distributor of metal stamping equipment
Enjoy iguazu falls & national park 2, 3 and 4 nights packages trips
GoToAssist Free Trial
Exclusive Offer for Remedy Users! Try Citrix GoToAssist For 30 Days.
While the first one could prove useful, the second sounds like more and heavier equipment than one would really need under the circumstances. Iguazu might be a bit far to go on my first big night out, although thanks for the tip. Given GoToAssist doesn’t explain itself very well, it could be more or less anything in this context; what kind of assistance are they offering? And what, under the circumstances, is a remedy user? (Somewhat anticlimactically, GoToAssist is software to remotely assist someone with their computer, which has a few romantic possibilites, I suppose.
I think we should stop being worred about Google knowing too much about us, and worrying that they don’t enough. In my case, they seem to have gotten the impression I’m some child hitting, coldsore ridden, machinery loving diaper wearer. Time to start sending myself some emails lauding my abilities, looks, experience and lack of facial blisters.
Google is not evil..but a learning process