Citizen Pundits
Forget citizen journalism. How about citizen punditry? An unnamed taxi driver IT specialist appeared on the BBC's news 24 after being mistaken for his fare, technology pundit Guy Kewney. Despite the BBC’s apparent efforts to suppress the moment, the Daily Mail has recovered it, according to Guy himself, who is rightly highly amused that his face, and ethnicity, are not particularly well known to BBC staff. You can download the clip here.
As Guy says, “you can watch the classic moment, where the cab driver realises that he is on air, and being mistaken for someone else, here. It's beyond classic: it's priceless. Watch his incredible recovery, and his determination to show that this may be a complete surprise to him, but that he can out-Kewney any darned NewsWireless Editor if he has to.”
The Times reports that “it is not the first time that the BBC has been embarrassed by a case of mistaken identity. Last year Rhodri Morgan, the First Minister of Wales, was mistaken for a cast member of Doctor Who when he was due to appear on the BBC Wales political show Dragon’s Eye.
Unfortunately the identity of the cabbie in question has not yet been established. He deserves a medal for his performance and to have his own show. I’m all in favour of this kind of thing. If only more television networks would take a broader, more inclusive view of what it means to be an “expert” we might all benefit.
[Update (thanks, Juha, for pointing out): The cabbie has been found, and he's not a cabbie, but a data cleansing expert. Not such a good story as the original, but nice to get it right.]
I didn't watch the clip, yet, but as a cab driver he probably didn't have much of a problem believing himself to be an expert, never mind on what, it's a problem many of them have.
As the old joke goes, it's a pity that the people who really know how the world should be managed are all too busy serving people drinks, cutting their hair, and driving them around...
Posted by: Yaron | May 15, 2006 at 11:22 PM
Guy Goma is not a taxi driver though... poor man can't be very happy about the sudden cabbiesation:
http://www.newswireless.net/index.cfm/article/2708
Posted by: Juha | May 16, 2006 at 06:29 AM