Closing The Door After The Phish Has Bolted

MasterCard, one of several banks discovered to have flaws on their websites that would have allowed a phisher to capture passwords, says it has fixed the problem.

American Banker Online reported (subscription required) last week that MasterCard International “has confirmed finding and fixing a flaw on its web site’s ‘Find A Card’ tool that could have facilitated a phishing scam”. The flaw had been discovered by British programmer Sam Greenhalgh and published on his web site on June 28. Greenhalgh lists in a sidebar those web sites that have been fixed or the flawed code removed. It’s not yet over: He says that PayPal and several sub-domains of Microsoft.com “remain susceptible”.

Besides the failure of some web sites to tackle the problem, a few other things worry me. 

  • Why did it take MasterCard three weeks to remove the flawed code? American Banker reports that the tool was removed on July 20. As Greenhalgh writes it’s probably a case of closing the door after the horse has bolted. (American Banker quotes MasterCard as saying that “It does not believe that any scams were attempted”.)
  • Why is no mention made of the flaw or the fix in MasterCard’s own ‘newsroom’? There are two releases trumpeting MasterCard’s own ‘fight on phishers’ but nothing of its own vulnerabilities.
  • How many more vulnerabilities are out there? Did Greenhalgh’s discovery trigger a serious audit of all code on such websites, or did they just plug the holes he had found?

Anyway, plaudits should be offered to Greenhalgh (so far I’ve not seen any from the banking fraternity, but I could be wrong) for his work and others encouraged to hunt for more leaks. Such folk are not troublemakers looking for nits to pick. They perform a very useful service. Phishing has shown that all this is no longer just theory, if it ever was. Every one of these vulnerabilities will be found and exploited if the good guys don’t get there first.

30. July 2004 by jeremy
Categories: Malware, Security | Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Closing The Door After The Phish Has Bolted