Can We Trust Anti-Spy Software?

Who watches over the watchers? In software, it seems, it’s often the same folk.
 
Reading a press release for X-Cleaner, “a privacy tool suite that detects and removes installed spyware and adware components”, it sounded interesting enough for a mention. After all, it “includes tools to securely delete files, edit the registry, disable startup programs”, as well as “IE home page protection, cookie, cache and history cleaning, built-in password generator and more”. What’s more, there’s a free version with some features disabled. Not a bad tool for those folk worried about keylogging phisher trojans and whatnot.
 
But when I tried to find out who the company is behind it — never easy with companies working outside the U.S., I find — I saw some of the other software sold by the same company. The company is called XKee, it does not reveal where it’s based (and the WHOIS registrant information for the website contains a UK-based email address and a half-complete New York mailing address). XKee says (and I reproduce the original formatting here) “WE DO NOT MAKE ANY OF THE SOFTWARE! EACH PRODUCT IS SUBMITTED BY A SOFTWARE COMPANY OR DEVELOPER, OR IS PICKED FROM THE INTERNET BY OUR EDITORS. WHAT WE DO IS REVIEW AND RATE THE SOFTWARE, CATEGORIZE IT AND MAKE IT AVAILABLE TO YOU.”
 
Among those products are:
  •  iSpyNOW, “the critically acclaimed, award winning remotely deployable computer monitoring application. iSpyNOW is first of its kind – offering users the ability to remotely monitor a machine via a web interface without ever having physical access to that PC. iSpyNOW 3.0 now sets a standard in the remote monitoring and surveillance market. Read below to see why iSpyNOW 3.0 is the most powerful remote surveillance software offered anywhere!”
  • SpyBuddy,  ”the award-winning, powerful spy software and computer monitoring product for monitoring spouses, children, co-workers, or just about anyone else! SpyBuddy allows you to monitor all areas of your PC, tracking every action down the last keystroke pressed or the last file deleted! SpyBuddy comes equipped with the functionality to record all AOL/ICQ/MSN/AIM/Yahoo chat conversations, all websites visited, all windows opened and interacted with, every application executed, every document printed, every file or folder renamed and/or modified, all text and images sent to the clipboard, every keystroke pressed, every password typed, and more!”

Now, I know that software sites such as this are not unusual, and it’s also not unusual that they’re going to sell software that plays both sides of the fence — snooping, and anti-snooping — but it made me wonder: In these days of sophisticated fakery, how do we know the anti-snooping software does what it says it does? How do we know the software is not doing its own kind of snooping, like the other products on sale? If a company is happily selling snooping software, how far can we trust them to sell us something that does what it says it does?

The answer in the case of X-Cleaner is this: Despite the similar sounding names, it does not appear that X-Cleaner is related to XKee. X-Cleaner, from what I can see, is a bona fide anti-spyware program produced in Belgium by a company called Xblock. It has been reviewed in PCWorld and elsewhere, so is probably kosher. But there’s no easy way of telling any of this by visiting the websites of XKee, X-Cleaner or Xblock. I could find no useful company page, nothing to identify the folk behind it and an address or something to grab a hold of.

My feeling is this: I’m sure XKee and companies are not into anything sleazy, but nowadays I think they have got be much more upfront about who they are if they want to be credible: Especially if they’re selling potentially law-breaking software like spyware and mass-mailers. We need a physical address, some names, a corporate identity that stands up to scrutiny and customer queries. For the user, I’d say this: Be wary of any software that promises to keep your privacy unless you’ve read a review by someone you respect, and you have a pretty good idea of who’s behind it. For columnists like me, I’m going to be more careful about what software I recommend in future. End of sermon.

22. February 2004 by jeremy
Categories: Software, apps | Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 16 comments

Comments (16)

  1. iSpyNow is just a scam and nothing else. I bought that pice of software and tried to intall in on several machines remotelly. I built the module, sent it per mail and I could not open attachement on the other side at all. All todays email providers user antivurus programs which detect iSpy module as a virus, even tell that it is a keylogger and block it from downloading or even sending per email. Such a crap … at cost or $90.

  2. Ispynow is bullshit!! IS NOT WORKING AT ALL. HAS BEEN DECECTED FROM A VERY COMMON ANTIVIRUS SUCH A AVG FEE EDITION. IT WONT INSTALL ANYWHERE AND THEY WONT GIVE YOU MONEY BACK. SOME OF US WANT SUE THEM IF YOU GOT TROUBLE WITH THEM LET ME KNOW. DONT BUY ISPYNOW IT’S A REAP OFF!!!

  3. iSPYNOW IS NOT WORKING AT ALL. THEY MAKE YOU SPEND FROM 76 TO 90 $ FOR A SOFTWARE THAT IS NOT WORKING!! AVG FREE EDITION IS DETECTING THE MODULE AND EVEN IF YOU UNINSTALL ALL YOUR ANTIVIRUS STILL NOT WORKING!! IT’S A REAP OFF. WE WANT TO SUE THEM!! IF YOU ASK FOR A REFOUND THEY WONT LISTEN TO YOU. WE TRY TO INSTALL THE MODULE IN MANY, MANY DIFFERENT MACHINE WITH DIFFERENT SYSTEM FROM WIN 2000 TO WIN XP HOME EDITION OR PROFESSIONAL AND IS NOT WORKING AT ALL! THEY ARE GETTING MONEY FROM PEOPLE SELLING SOMETHING THAT IS NOT WORKING!! IT’S A FRAUD

  4. Power Spy lets you know exactly what a user did on a PC. It does this stealthily so that the user won’t know such monitoring exists. Possible usages of Power Spy include: monitors employees, children, spouse, acquire others’ passwords, chat records, websites visited and investigate crimes. It sends the record to a pre- determined email address. You can also view the record on the monitored computer. Power Spy can run in a stealth mode and with password protected, so no one except you is aware of their existence, and the password can prevent other people from terminating or uninstalling them.

  5. Pingback: Anti Spyware Review

  6. SpyBuddy it’s a very useful tool for me
    ( http://www.soft82.com/downloads/Windows/SpyBuddy )

  7. SpyBuddy it’s a very useful tool for me
    ( http://www.soft82.com/downloads/Windows/SpyBuddy )

  8. Try the new version of SpyBuddy who track every action down the last keystroke pressed or the last file deleted

  9. I am using SpyBuddy(http://www.softdownload22.com/pagina_produs.php?variabila1=2164) for some time and I think it’s ok

  10. I am using SpyBuddy(http://www.softdownload22.com/pagina_produs.php?variabila1=2164) for some time and I think it’s ok

  11. To those of you who who paid for ispynow and got ripped off…. BOO HOO. Sorry, but if you’re going to try spying on people, you deserve to end up in that situation. Stay on your own computer. kthx